Bryce Underwood made history in 2025 as the first true freshman quarterback to start for Michigan since 2009. He set a program record for a freshman QB in his debut, throwing for 251 yards without a turnover.

But not everyone is convinced he belongs under center. Former Super Bowl champion Eric Weddle didn't think Underwood makes it as QB1.

Speaking candidly on the Zero2Sixty podcast, the former All-Pro safety made a pointed statement about the young signal-caller's future in Ann Arbor.

"Mark my words… don't be surprised if the backups are playing early. That Underwood kid. I don't think you can throw or play quarterback," Weddle said. "I don't understand how the position isn't being taught from the pocket."

Weddle's criticism comes despite Underwood's statistically solid freshman campaign.

The Michigan quarterback threw for 2,428 yards and 11 touchdowns while rushing for 392 yards and 6 scores. He started all 13 games, becoming only the fourth true freshman QB to start for the Wolverines.

Underwood's numbers also revealed clear areas for growth. He averaged 216 total yards per game and completed just over 60 percent of his passes.

Whether Weddle's prediction proves accurate depends largely on the new offensive coordinator, Jason Beck.

Beck's track record includes top-five national offensive rankings at Utah and New Mexico, plus a history of developing dual-threat quarterbacks. As Michigan enters summer conditioning, all eyes are on Underwood's growth.

Despite Weddle's doubt in Underwood's ability, the QB is in high spirits ahead of the 2026 season.

Bryce Underwood Brims With Confidence Ahead Of 2026 Season

Bryce Underwood's talents might come under scrutiny, but he is still upbeat about the team's prospects in the season ahead.

"We went through a lot, but I think we’re going to be more player-led this season. I feel like we are more of a team now," said Underwood.

According to NBC analyst Todd Blackledge, Underwood is already showing signs of growth under Beck's guidance.

"I think he definitely looks more comfortable, even though it's a different system," Blackledge told Wolverines Wire. "He's a very serious kid when it comes to work, training, and preparation. He wants to be great. He wants to be coached."

Ever since Kyle Whittingham has taken over the reigns there has been a spring in the step for Michigan. The former Utah coach now also has Jason Beck to handle his offense. Beck, who joined this year as the offensive coordinator, is regarded highly.

Beck's track record includes top‑five national offensive rankings at Utah (2025) and New Mexico (2024). He also had prior success mentoring QBs at Syracuse and Virginia.

Next in line for Michigan is summer conditioning. This will be followed by fall camp in August. All eyes of the Michigan fanbase will then be on how Beck elevated Underwood's game.

Read more at the Michigan Football Community!

Written by

Sourav Ganguly

Edited by

Kalp Thaker