
Michigan quarterback Bryce Underwood (19) looks on during warmup at Michigan Stadium in Ann Arbor on Saturday, Nov. 29, 2025.
Michigan quarterback Bryce Underwood (19) looks on during warmup at Michigan Stadium in Ann Arbor on Saturday, Nov. 29, 2025.
Jul 4, 2026, 10:30 AM CUT
David Pollack defends Bryce Underwood’s controversial “best player” declaration after public outrage
Quarterback Bryce Underwood said something at a youth camp this week that set the internet on fire. ESPN analyst David Pollack was one of the few voices that didn't go after him for it.
"Confidence is a prerequisite for success in football. And confidence based on fact is not arrogance. There aren't a lot of facts to back this claim up, but Mr. Underwood has plenty of time to change our minds. I'll have my popcorn ready!" Pollack posted per his X account.
The clip that started all of it came from a youth camp interview posted by Click On Detroit.
"I want to prove to myself that I am what I think I am," Underwood said in the interview. "I feel like I'm the best player to ever come out of Michigan. Now it's time for me to show that, because I worked for it,".
When asked if he was working differently under Kyle Whittingham's new staff, he kept it short. "I'm working smarter than I was last year."
The outrage online was instant. The problem people had wasn't the confidence. It was the name Underwood was putting himself ahead of.
Michigan has produced Tom Brady, Charles Woodson, and Desmond Howard. Calling yourself the best player to ever come out of the program as a sophomore with one difficult season on tape was always going to land hard.
His freshman numbers gave the critics plenty to work with, too. 202 completions out of 335 attempts, 2,428 yards, 11 touchdowns, eight interceptions. That's what his freshman year looked like on paper. For the kid who came in with a $10.5 million NIL deal and the No. 1 recruit tag, that wasn't it.
Pollack's take on the other side is simple, though. Quarterbacks who don't back themselves don't usually make it. The belief has to be there before the results are. What Underwood said wasn't surprising for someone with his background. What matters now is what he does with it come September.
Bryce Underwood has faced non-stop scrutiny all offseason and still hasn’t backed down
This isn't the first time Underwood's name has been in the news this offseason for the wrong reasons. Former NFL safety Eric Weddle attended Michigan's spring practice and publicly said Underwood couldn't throw.
Todd McShay followed up on the Rich Eisen Show saying his freshman year "does not cut it," per the Rich Eisen Show.
Then a message board rumor started circulating that Whittingham's staff was trying to bring in Utah quarterback Devon Dampier to replace him in 2027. The program never confirmed it, and most people didn't buy it.
Through all of it, Underwood has kept showing up and kept saying the same thing. He believes he's the best. Every analyst, former player, and internet account that disagrees just adds to the list of people he says he's going to prove wrong.
That's either the mentality of a player about to have a breakout year or a storyline that follows him all season. September answers that.
Do you think Bryce Underwood can back up his bold claim this season? Let us know in the comments.
Written by

Farheen Fathima
Edited by
Zaid Quraishi